Conservatives and Activists Displeased with Immigration Deal
The recently proposed immigration bill is causing a stir among conservatives and activists alike. The bill aims to address the issue of high migration levels and streamline the asylum process while providing additional work permits and funding for staffing. However, critics argue that the bill will regularize illegal immigration, fund non-governmental organizations, and fail to provide relief for current illegal immigrants.
Conservatives Raise Concerns
Conservatives, particularly in the Republican-controlled House, have voiced their opposition to the bill. They argue that it will normalize high levels of illegal immigration and allocate funds to non-governmental organizations that support undocumented migrants. Additionally, they take issue with the provision of legal aid to illegal immigrants.
Activists Demand More
On the other hand, activists on the left are dissatisfied with the bill for different reasons. Immigrant activists argue that the bill does not provide any form of amnesty for undocumented immigrants already in the country, including those who came as minors (known as “Dreamers”). They claim that the bill harms migrants without offering them relief.
Criticism from Rights Groups and Lawmakers
Several rights groups and lawmakers have criticized the proposed bill, citing concerns about due process and the treatment of refugees and migrants.
American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) Sounds Alarm
The ACLU, which has been actively involved in lawsuits against immigration policies, including Title 42, expressed their concerns about the bill. They argue that it would “force the government to summarily expel people from the border without due process.” The ACLU also believes that the bill fails to address the immigration case backlog and provide pathways to citizenship for Dreamers and longtime residents.
American Immigration Council Calls for Improvement
The American Immigration Council acknowledges the bipartisan effort to address the unsustainable situation at the southern border but expresses disappointment with the bill’s outcome. They appreciate certain positive measures, such as an overall increase in green cards, but criticize the bill for its silence on the plight of Dreamers. They also oppose the proposal for summary expulsions, which they argue have proven to be harmful and counterproductive under previous administrations.
Human Rights First Accuses Washington of Playing Politics
Human Rights First accuses government leaders of prioritizing politics over the lives of refugees and migrants. They argue that denying individuals the right to seek safety and protection based on their place in line is unjust. The organization calls for an end to partisan posturing and political games.
Lawmakers Express Strong Opposition
Lawmakers in the Senate who have advocated for pathways to citizenship for undocumented immigrants also expressed their dismay with the bill. Senator Bob Menendez, who led the push for the 2021 immigration reform bill supported by the Biden administration, called the proposed bill unacceptable. He accuses Senate leadership of reneging on their commitment to allow meaningful input from the Congressional Hispanic Caucus and warns that accepting the bill as written would be a betrayal to the communities they represent.
Biden Administration Stands Firm
Despite the opposition, President Biden, Vice President Harris, and DHS Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas continue to urge the passage of the bill. They believe it is a necessary step in addressing the immigration issue and reshaping America’s immigration system.
